After the phenomenal response to my top movies list (all seven of you who heard the podcast and criticized my picks), I have decided to put together my list of top albums from 2006. Even moreso than the film list, this one has been really tough to compile. I am a music freak. I love films, TV, and comics, but music runs through my veins. My first recollections of music include being struck with awe after hearing the double-LP soundtrack to Star Wars as a young child, even before seeing the film. I listened to those two records non-stop, the themes and movements getting seared into my brain. From then on, it was a constant diet of Gershwin, more John Williams, classical composers, The Beatles, and a steady stream of discovering the massive amount of musical creativity that was rock and roll in the 60’s and 70’s. From there I moved into modern rock, punk, hardcore…and the rest is history.
Given the new levels of accessibility to music online, it’s gotten pretty tough to buy albums that I don’t like. Whether it’s through mp3 leaks, streaming audio on MySpace or Purevolume, or song snippets on iTunes, it is incredibly easy to check out an album before buying, saving all of us money and frustration. That said, I still ended up getting 27 albums this year, with an additional 12 waiting in the wings until I have the funds to purchase them. Even in this day and age of digital song downloads, I remain a huge fan of the physical album. I like being able to take it with me, read the liner notes, look at the art…in my mind, it’s all part of the experience of listening to an album. All this simply to say, I enjoyed every single one of the albums I got this year. I’ll go out on a limb from time to time if I spot a great deal on a used album that I’m curious about…but the previously mentioned access to music online makes it so easy to test the waters before buying.
So this was, as I said before, a tough list to put together. I try to judge the music on a few levels: how it initially hit me, how it’s grown on me since getting it, and, somewhat tenuously, whether I think it’s got staying power long-term. Here we go…and with a tip of the hat to Spinal Tap, this list goes to 11:

11. Murder By Death - In Bocca Al Lupo
Murder By Death is something of an anomaly in the punk scene. They’re really an indie rock band with influences from Johnny Cash, barfights, and sea chantie. They’re the only rock band I’ve ever that had to cut their set short because their cellist was rocking too hard and broke one of her strings. This album is simply phenomenal. World-weary, downtrodden, and heavy-hearted. Redemption is possible, but it’s sometimes a hard road back.

10. Lupe Fiasco - Food & Liquor
I am not a hip-hop expert by any means, but I know what I like when it comes to the genre…and Lupe’s debut album is it. Tight rhymes, sweet instrumentation, and socially conscious. I dig it. I can’t wait to see where he goes from here.

9. The Mars Volta - Amputechture
The Mars Volta is one of those love/hate bands. You either get ‘em or you don’t. And by that I don’t mean there’s some sort of deep secret to understanding these guys…I just think that the music either speaks to you or it doesn’t. There’s not much middle ground. Obviously by their presence here, I love ‘em. This still doesn’t top their debut, De-Loused In The Comatorium, but it’s still an incredible piece of experimental rock. With influences far too numerous to list here, The Mars Volta pack a wallop each time they release an album.

8. Taking Back Sunday - Louder Now
A few albums on this list took a while to click with me. This was one. While I loved the first single, “Makedamnsure,” most of the record fell flat when I first got it. A few months later, I dug it out for a second try and now I love it. Fantastic punk-influenced rock, this is one solid album, from start to finish.

7. Johnny Cash - American V: A Hundred Highways
There’s not much, if anything at all, that I can say about Johnny Cash’s legacy that hasn’t already been said. I love his music and this posthumous album is no different. Even on the edge of stepping into eternity, Cash’s voice still retains power, conviction, and strength. What an incredible man, musician, and legend.

6. Far-Less - Everyone Is Out To Get Us
Here’s another one of the growers in this list. I picked up their EP, “Turn To The Bright,” before getting this and fell in love with their melodic rock chaos. This album didn’t hit me with the same immediacy as the EP, but now that I’ve had time to listen through it numerous times, I’m into it a ton. Far-Less is another band that I’m excited about watching as they grow and develop.

5. He Is Legend - Suck Out The Poison
Holy crap. Talk about musical boot to the ass. He Is Legend took the hardcore roots of their earlier roots and distilled them into a dirty southern rock album that’s easily a close (inbred?) cousin to the debut last year from Maylene and the Sons of Disaster. Heavy, dark, rockin’…this whole record riffs on the darker side of fairy tales and humanity. Freakin’ awesome.

4. mewithoutYou - Brother, Sister
mewithoutYou have managed to amaze and surprise me. While I loved their debut record, their second, “Catch For Us The Foxes,” left me somewhat cold. But when I heard about the appearance of Jeremy Enigk on two of the tracks here, my anticipatory excitement knew no bounds. Thankfully I wasn’t disappointed. This is a beautiful indie rock album, lyrically and musically. The pacing, the flow…everything works. Oh and those two songs with Jeremy Enigk? Top-notch.

3. Stavesacre - How To Live With A Curse
Stavesacre is a band that has meant so much to me over the past few years. Without a doubt, they are one of my favorite bands of all time. Mark Salomon’s voice moves me like few do and his lyrics are like mainlining inspiration. Their last full album was a big let-down and I was afraid that it might be the final word of their career. But then they released this puppy and my fears were completely destroyed. This is, pure and simple, an outstanding rock record. Buy it. Listen. Love it.

2. Jeremy Enigk - World Waits
These last two picks were tough. Jeremy Enigk is a god among men, as far as music is concerned. This album could have easily been number one. Whether it’s through Sunny Day Real Estate, The Fire Theft, or his solo stuff, the music he creates is on another level from most of the rest of us. Stunning, beautiful, and incredibly moving. I was finally able to see him live this year and it was an experience like none other. His voice alone puts him in a rare league and he’s got the song writing chops to back it up.

1. Underoath - Define The Great Line
Man, what a year it’s been for Underoath. They released this album to a huge amount of fanfare, appeared on and later left the Warped Tour with rumors of a break-up swirling, the record went gold, and they’ve since returned to the touring circuit…they’ve weathered it all and have come out intact. This album might as well be the soundtrack to the emotions and experiences they’ve faced all year. It’s brutal, heavy, compelling, complex, beautiful, and incredibly moving. I liked it okay the first few times I listened to it. Now that I’ve had more time to hear the layers and depth, I absolutely love it. What a triumph.
Whew. There you have it. My top eleven records of 2006. Enjoy it. Hate it. Listen for yourself and see what you think.